Middle Chick
Middle chick is a girl your talking to that your not sure about. Sure you'd like to have sex with her but your not 100% sure about it for various reasons including how much you actually like her, how crazy she is, etc.
I been talking to Jane but ehh shes a middle chick so who knows whats going happen, shes got lots of potential.
or
John keeps wasting time on that middle chick.
or
John keeps wasting time on that middle chick.