overunderrated
Something that is underrated, but not nearly as great as those claiming so would have you to believe
Shadow of the Colossus is an overunderrated video game; people love it, but it's boring and looks like crap.
Overunderrated
A Piece Of Media That Is Known By A Lot Of People But Should Be Known By More People
Hey Arnold! And Mr Roboto Are 2 Great Cases Of Overunderrated Media A Lot Of People Love And Cherish Them But A Lot More People Could