punmanship
(n). The quality and/or smoothness of one's puns.
Elana has poor punmanship; she thought saying "My feet are sunburnt - tomaTOES!" was clever.
George: "Whoever served that wine did a pour job."
Michelle: "Wow, dude. You've got great punmanship."
George: "Whoever served that wine did a pour job."
Michelle: "Wow, dude. You've got great punmanship."