Rusty Revenge
For the guy that a group has a strong hatred/dislike for. Pretend to want to have gang bang with a hot girl. Tell him he is on bottom for the DP. Then while the girl sits on him, everyone holds him down in one way or another (handcuffs are ideal). The girl proceeds to take a shit on top of him. The guys piss on him, and a huge dildo is forced up his ass. The guys can then take turns taking a shit on him. Photos will be taken as a blackmail tool to address the issue that causes the hatred.
A viable option in this case is to give him a Rusty Revenge in order to stop him.