fail gay
to be unflaboyant or uninitiated in commonly gay convention despite actually being gay
to fail at being gay
to fail at being gay
"wow.. what a fail gay"
Gay Fail Face
A face made by a gay guy, usually when taking a photograph, whereas the said gay guy's lips are pooched out in an effort to look like a cracked out model. Possibly inspired by Derek Zoolander's signature pose, Blue Steel.
Oh, Blaine is soooo gay. He has Gay Fail Face in almost all of his Facebook pictures.